Tingley Rubber Overshoe Cover is rated
3.0 out of
5 by
24.
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Lara from
Exactly what I hoped for
I was hesitant to buy this product after seeing some of the questionable reviews, but as long as you check the sizing, it does work. I wear a US Women’s size 10 boot, ordered a medium, and they fit perfectly and are watertight. Can even ride in them, as they aren’t particularly bulky, which is a plus for me. Below are pictures after use.
Date published: 2022-01-06
Rated 2 out of
5
by
AnnetteB from
No longer in women’s sizes! Too big
I’ve loved my old Tingley Rubbers for years, but noticed I can no longer find them. I was really excited to see these back on Smartpak, but was disappointed. The small is more like a men’s “small”. I wear a 6.5 women’s shoe and this is way too big! While this doesn’t fit my Ariat paddock boots, it nearly fits my tall Cavallo boots which have a longer toe. I wish there was a way to get the women’s sizes again!
Date published: 2021-01-11
Rated 3 out of
5
by
dressageonly from
Just OK
These are not like the good old Tingley rubbers. As others have said the heel is huge on these rubbers. I wear them over my paddock boots around the barn. I wear a size 8 boot and ordered the small. They fit OK and do keep my paddock boots dry. I would not recommend riding in them as it's impossible to pull the back heel area up far enough have a tight fit on your boots.
Date published: 2020-06-26
Rated 1 out of
5
by
carol from
Not good-boot rubbers
I used to have some old ones that were just wonderful. The new ones are awful, too big, weird fit around the heel, they cracked and leaked. Worst of all, they stick to the stirrup and when I dismount the rubbers stick to the stirrup bottom and I near had a bad fall dismounting, Cannot recommend them, they are dangerous.
Date published: 2019-02-13
Rated 3 out of
5
by
Liza from
Trim sized?
I have used these for decades but not for several years. These came in a trim size which was just too narrow. I am sure they would do the job if I could get them on. So only 3 stars
Date published: 2019-01-08
Rated 3 out of
5
by
Horseslave from
Ok, not great!
Soooooo....like everyone has said, these are not the old Tingley's! The fit in the heel is very weird (big!). After reading the reviews, I searched online for another brand, but couldn't find anything decent that might look good, and hold up on a tall boot. Because of Smartpak's free return shipping, I decided to give them a try. Despite looking kind of weird, they actually did fit ok, with the exception of the heel which is big. I wondered if they would come off when I walked! Since I had nothing else, and I wanted to protect my knew boots, I kept them. Surprisingly, they do stay on. But they look kind of odd, and I'm not sure if they would stay on for hours of walking. If you board your horse and you use these to walk from the car to the barn and back, they may work. If you are a trainer walking around the ring all day wearing them, I don't know if these would be a good idea! Plus they don't look too professional because of the awkward fit! The smartpak rep said she would email the product development people to see if they could get another brand in.
Date published: 2018-06-13
Rated 1 out of
5
by
Sandi0905 from
Do not like the new sizing.
I live in my tall boots with tingleys on them while teaching/riding. My old ones finally died and I had to replace them. The sizing has changed. I am a ladies 7 in shoes I ordered the small which is supposed to fit 7-8.5.....these are definately meant to fit the larger boot. I had way too much extra rubber/heel at the back of my boot and would have bee dragging it around. I found an old pair on another website with the old fit. They also made them shiny.....no thanks I don't want attention brought to the fact that I am wearing them. I do not reccomend.
Date published: 2017-11-21
Rated 1 out of
5
by
Marcy96161 from
Bad sizing
I really wish they would come in a ladies size the one size you have is a mans size
Date published: 2017-10-16
Rated 1 out of
5
by
MarL from
Very odd shape shoe cover
This shoe cover looks like it should be for a pointy pair of mens shoes. Dont know how it is being marketed for barn or riding shoes. I had to make a cut on the top to try & get a better fit- wrong move- they split all the way down. Totally wasted $25-so sad.
Date published: 2017-08-02
Rated 3 out of
5
by
Horsemom from
Big
These are bigger and uglier than they used to be. I used to wear a size medium but this time I had to exchange them for a small. And they're still a bit too big. They make my feet look like Herman Meunster but they are functional and protect my paddock boots.
Date published: 2017-07-16