Skip to content
PLEASE NOTE: You may experience errors on our site when using Internet Explorer. Please consider updating your browser, or download Google Chrome.

Tingley Rubber Overshoe Cover

Our Price: List Price:
Our Price: Our Price: Sale Price: : $ (%) :
Member Price:
(Members save 5% at SmartPak)
SmartPerks Price:
(Because you have supplements on AutoShip, you save an extra 10% on this and all other SmartPak tack & apparel items!)
Your Price:
(You save 5% as a member of . And, because you have supplements on AutoShip, you save an extra 10% on this and all other SmartPak tack & apparel items!)
SmartPerks Price:
(Because you have supplements on AutoShip, you can save an extra 10% on this and all other SmartPak tack & apparel items! Enter promo code PERKS at checkout.)
Your Price:
(You save 5% as a member of . Because you have supplements on AutoShip, you can save an extra 10% on this and all other SmartPak tack & apparel items! Enter promo code PERKS at checkout.)
Free Shipping (Details)
Ships free with a qualifying item
Free Return Shipping
Free Return Shipping

As riders and online shoppers, we know it can be tough to buy a new bridle or pair of boots without trying them on. That's why we moved the fitting room to your living room (or barn)! From breeches to blankets, if you or your horse can try it on, you can return it, free! Just request a return with a FREE SmartPak return label from your Order History within 60 days of the purchase date. And of course, please make sure the item is in like-new condition with original packaging (we said 'fitting room', not 'war room'!).

Customize your program:

FINAL SALE - This item cannot be returned or exchanged.

FINAL SALE - This item cannot be returned or exchanged.

- +
Required (Optional)
on every AutoShip order (Details)
You'll love our AutoShip because it's:
  • Focused on happy riders - never worry about running out!
  • Easy to snooze or cancel online, anytime
  • Totally flexible - edit your order as often as you'd like
PLUS! You'll save % on every shipment if you order this product on AutoShip
You'll love our AutoShip because it's:
  • Focused on healthy s, because consistency is key
  • Easy to snooze or cancel online, anytime
  • Totally flexible - edit your order as often as you'd like
  • Your VIP pass to FREE SmartPerks benefits
PLUS! You'll save % on every shipment if you order this product on AutoShip
Price for one-time shipment:
AutoShip price: Price per shipment:
AutoShip Savings applied
Start date: Customize your program for estimated start date. View estimated schedule
Zone Map
Begin with the zone for the state you are in. Dates shown on the map indicate suggested start and end dates for Fly Stoppers™ shipments. You may want to shift a zone if your elevation or microclimate is unusual, or if you fall on the border between two zones. You can start anytime during the fly season. Choose "Year Round" for climates that have flies all year, and start now.
Program Type Shipment/Application Frequency
Regular Programs: Ships every 4 weeks. For low to average fly levels, frequent manure management and few neighbors.
Premium Programs: Ships every 3 weeks. For high fly levels or weekly manure management or nearby livestock.
of max 255 characters used
Just left - order today! Don't wait - just a few left!
These are for:
Sign in to choose an existing
Order within and have it by Shipping to
Add these items to your cart to get your estimated arrival date. Shipping to
Guaranteed Holiday Delivery:
Standard product delivery is but may take longer due to holiday volume.
All customized items are personalized in our Plymouth, MA facility, and it looks like this item is currently out of stock in that location.
Please call 1-800-461-8898 to order this product.
We're bringing you this product at the lowest price allowed by the manufacturer so you won't find it cheaper anywhere else. This also means we can't apply any further discounts or promotions.

SmartPerks Putting your horse's supplements on AutoShip helps you take great care of your horse, so we take great care of you with SmartPerks! When you order your horse's supplements on AutoShip, you're automatically* eligible for our FREE SmartPerks benefits, including:

  • Free shipping every day
  • 10% off all SmartPak brand tack, apparel, and gear

Learn more about SmartPerks

*At least one individual AutoShip supplement or horse's SmartPaks must be over $40. Some exclusions apply. Visit or call 1-800-461-8898 for details.


Why We Love This

A wet environment at the barn can be damaging for your leather boots and we have the solution with the Tingley Rubber Overshoe Cover. This 100% waterproof overshoe will protect your investment from rain, snow, salt damage splashing water buckets and wash stalls. Designed for use around the barn adding extra traction on slippery surfaces and should be removed before riding as they aren't intended for use in a stirrup. Fits over virtually every shoe style and size and are made to last.

  • Protects your entire shoe in rain or snow
  • Perfect, comfortable fit over any style shoe
  • Prevents damage from rain, mud, snow and salt
  • 100% waterproof protection
  • High stretch natural rubber for easy on and off
  • Exceptional fit and comfort
  • Lightweight, yet tough and durable
  • Tear resistant
  • Tread designed for extra traction on slippery surfaces
  • 100% Happiness Guarantee
    100% Happiness Guarantee
    At SmartPak, your happiness is at the core of everything we do. We put our products to the test in our barns and on our horses, and back every order with our world-class customer service so that you can shop with confidence. As part of our Happiness Guarantee, we promise you:
    • Expert advice from riders
    • Free shipping every day
    • Free return shipping on sized items
    • Hassle-free returns up to 365 days after purchase
(Maintenance Dose = )
Ingredient Amount
Unisex sizing please measure according to size chart to get the closest fit!
What Customers Say:
Sizing Chart for Tingley Rubber Overshoe Cover
Tingley Rubber Overshoe Cover is rated 3.0 out of 5 by 23.
Rated 2 out of 5 by from No longer in women’s sizes! Too big I’ve loved my old Tingley Rubbers for years, but noticed I can no longer find them. I was really excited to see these back on Smartpak, but was disappointed. The small is more like a men’s “small”. I wear a 6.5 women’s shoe and this is way too big! While this doesn’t fit my Ariat paddock boots, it nearly fits my tall Cavallo boots which have a longer toe. I wish there was a way to get the women’s sizes again!
Date published: 2021-01-11
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Just OK These are not like the good old Tingley rubbers. As others have said the heel is huge on these rubbers. I wear them over my paddock boots around the barn. I wear a size 8 boot and ordered the small. They fit OK and do keep my paddock boots dry. I would not recommend riding in them as it's impossible to pull the back heel area up far enough have a tight fit on your boots.
Date published: 2020-06-26
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Not good-boot rubbers I used to have some old ones that were just wonderful. The new ones are awful, too big, weird fit around the heel, they cracked and leaked. Worst of all, they stick to the stirrup and when I dismount the rubbers stick to the stirrup bottom and I near had a bad fall dismounting, Cannot recommend them, they are dangerous.
Date published: 2019-02-13
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Trim sized? I have used these for decades but not for several years. These came in a trim size which was just too narrow. I am sure they would do the job if I could get them on. So only 3 stars
Date published: 2019-01-08
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Ok, not great! everyone has said, these are not the old Tingley's! The fit in the heel is very weird (big!). After reading the reviews, I searched online for another brand, but couldn't find anything decent that might look good, and hold up on a tall boot. Because of Smartpak's free return shipping, I decided to give them a try. Despite looking kind of weird, they actually did fit ok, with the exception of the heel which is big. I wondered if they would come off when I walked! Since I had nothing else, and I wanted to protect my knew boots, I kept them. Surprisingly, they do stay on. But they look kind of odd, and I'm not sure if they would stay on for hours of walking. If you board your horse and you use these to walk from the car to the barn and back, they may work. If you are a trainer walking around the ring all day wearing them, I don't know if these would be a good idea! Plus they don't look too professional because of the awkward fit! The smartpak rep said she would email the product development people to see if they could get another brand in.
Date published: 2018-06-13
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Do not like the new sizing. I live in my tall boots with tingleys on them while teaching/riding. My old ones finally died and I had to replace them. The sizing has changed. I am a ladies 7 in shoes I ordered the small which is supposed to fit 7-8.5.....these are definately meant to fit the larger boot. I had way too much extra rubber/heel at the back of my boot and would have bee dragging it around. I found an old pair on another website with the old fit. They also made them thanks I don't want attention brought to the fact that I am wearing them. I do not reccomend.
Date published: 2017-11-21
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Bad sizing I really wish they would come in a ladies size the one size you have is a mans size
Date published: 2017-10-16
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Very odd shape shoe cover This shoe cover looks like it should be for a pointy pair of mens shoes. Dont know how it is being marketed for barn or riding shoes. I had to make a cut on the top to try & get a better fit- wrong move- they split all the way down. Totally wasted $25-so sad.
Date published: 2017-08-02
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Big These are bigger and uglier than they used to be. I used to wear a size medium but this time I had to exchange them for a small. And they're still a bit too big. They make my feet look like Herman Meunster but they are functional and protect my paddock boots.
Date published: 2017-07-16
Rated 1 out of 5 by from Awful Bought these in a size small even after seeing that they changed the mold just because I was hoping they would magically fit. They don't. These will not fit you unless your a size 9 or above and that's the small size. Clearly mismeasured in factory - unisex is not a acurate label for shoes!!! I had a old style pair in small/ med that lasted 8 years!! I want the old style back!
Date published: 2017-06-06
  • y_2021, m_9, d_15, h_2
  • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvrr, vn_bulk_3.0.19
  • cp_1, bvpage1
  • co_hasreviews, tv_1, tr_22
  • loc_en_US, sid_11470, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=SUBMISSION_TIME, direction=DESCENDING)]
  • clientName_smartpak
  • bvseo_sdk, net_sdk,
  • CLOUD, getContent, 62ms
Q & A

Recently Viewed

Qualifying Items

Qualifying items are eligible for free shipping, every day. Look for the badge below on the product page to confirm that your item ships free!
Free Shipping

Ride Along Items

Ride Along items are eligible for free shipping when shipped with your next AutoShip order or any qualifying item. Look for the badge below to identify a Ride Along item.
Ride Along Item
Ships free with a qualifying item
All of our supplement and product expertise is just a text away. Ask questions, manage your account, and place orders by texting 26756 from your mobile phone. Have a great ride!

Our experts are available
Monday – Thursday 9:00 am – 5:00 pm EST
Friday 9:00 am – 3:00 pm EST

*By texting 26756, you're giving SmartPak your consent to text you to help resolve your issue, including automated replies, at the number you provided. To opt out, text STOP to 26756. Text HELP to 26756 for info. Msg&rates may apply. Consent to receive texts not required to buy products. Terms & conditions and the full Text Message Privacy Policy can be found at in case you're interested.